▶ PLAY
SP 2:35:41
Reviews / Sci-Fi / Project Hail Mary

Project Hail Mary — Two Thumbs Up. Authorities Have Been Notified.

Dir. Phil Lord & Christopher Miller Runtime 2h 36m Reviewed Aug 12, 2026 Sci-Fi · Now Playing · 2026
Matt
Thumb Up
Norm
Thumb Up
>> Official Verdict: Two Thumbs Up — A Miracle <<
DOUBLE-UP DETECTED · THIS IS NOT A DRILLHISTORICAL ANOMALY · NORM SAT THROUGH 2h 36m VOLUNTARILY

The 20-Second Version

Ryan Gosling wakes up alone on a spaceship with amnesia, a dying sun, and a molecular biology degree, and somehow this produced the rarest event this site records: a genuine double-up. Norm voluntarily sat through 156 minutes and called the runtime 'earned,' a phrase our archivists cannot find him using before. Matt wept at a spreadsheet. Management was not required and would like the record to show he agrees anyway.

Matt's Take

Thumb Up — Without a Single Caveat

This is the one. A $200 million spectacle where the hero’s superpower is doing science under deadline — no cape, no chosen one, just a terrified middle-school teacher (Ryan Gosling, never better at being ordinary) alone in a tin can, working the problem. Drew Goddard wrote The Martian and it shows: the movie treats competence like an action sequence, and Greig Fraser shoots deep space like it owes him money. And the mid-film introduction I refuse to spoil is the best character work of the year, delivered by something that shouldn’t be able to deliver character work at all.

“This is what I mean when I say they don’t make them like they used to — except this time they went ahead and MADE one.”

I laughed, I did some light crying at a lab result, and I walked out wanting to shake a scientist’s hand. If the practical-model people don’t win every award available, I’ll be writing letters. Thumb up. All the way. No footnotes.

Norm's Take

Thumb Up — Voluntarily, Somehow

Facts first: 156 minutes. That is 48 minutes over the House Rule and I am not filing the tax, because for once every minute is doing paid work. The plot is a promise the film actually keeps — set up, pay off, no flashback padding, no third act that dissolves into weather. Smart science fiction where “smart” describes the script and not the marketing.

“One hundred fifty-six minutes and I checked my watch exactly once — to see how much of the movie I had LEFT. Write that down. Notarize it.”

There is no Tom Cruise in this film, and I have decided to treat that as a rounding error rather than a flaw — the first picture since Collateral to earn the exemption. Gosling does the thing I ask of every lead: he convinces me the character is smarter than the screenwriter needed him to be. A thumb up, given freely, in public, on the record. The scoreboard will reflect it and I will hear no follow-up questions.

The Crossfire

Where the critics stop reviewing the movie and start reviewing each other.
MattWe agreed on something. Two reviews in one week. I genuinely don't know how to behave.
NormDon't make it weird. The film was correct, I said so, the ledger is updated. This is a normal transaction between professionals.
MattTwo double-ups on the books now. People are going to start thinking we like movies.
NormLet them think it. Statistically it corrects itself by Labor Day.

The Bottom Line

MattWatch it.
NormWatch it.
Verdict Two Thumbs Up